What Changed in 2024 — and What Did Not
The 2024 National Association of REALTORS practice changes (effective August 17, 2024 nationally and integrated into the California Association of REALTORS standard forms shortly thereafter) changed two specific things. First, compensation offered to a buyer's broker can no longer be advertised on most multiple listing services. Listing brokerages and sellers may still offer buyer-broker compensation, but the offer is communicated outside the MLS — through marketing materials, agent-to-agent discussions, or directly in negotiation. Second, buyers must enter into a written buyer representation agreement with their broker prior to touring properties, and that agreement must disclose how the buyer's broker is compensated.
What did not change: compensation has always been negotiable, listing-side compensation has always been negotiated between seller and listing brokerage, and the seller has always had the option to offer or not offer buyer-broker compensation. The changes formalized practices that were already legally permissible but were sometimes handled with less written clarity.
How Listing-Side Compensation Is Negotiated
The seller and the listing brokerage negotiate the listing-side compensation in the listing agreement. The customary structure in LA luxury is a total commission expressed as a percentage of the eventual sale price, with the listing brokerage retaining a portion and offering the balance to a cooperating buyer's broker. Total compensation in 2026 in LA luxury typically lands in a 3 to 6 percent range across price tiers, with lower percentages more common at higher price points (a $20M listing rarely pays the same percentage as a $2M listing).
What sellers should negotiate is not just the headline number but the structure. Considerations include: a tiered structure (lower percentage on the first dollars, higher on price achieved above a target); listing-side-only structures with no advertised cooperative compensation (and clear communication about how buyer's brokers will be handled); flat-fee or hybrid structures for situations where price is highly predictable; marketing-budget commitments by the listing brokerage; and the duration of the listing agreement.
How Buyer-Side Compensation Is Negotiated
Buyer-broker compensation is negotiated between the buyer and the buyer's broker through a written buyer representation agreement. The agreement defines the broker's compensation, which may be: a percentage of purchase price; a flat fee; an hourly rate; or a hybrid. The agreement also defines how compensation is paid — through seller-offered cooperative compensation, directly by the buyer, or some combination.
In practice, on most LA luxury transactions in 2026, the seller continues to offer buyer-broker compensation as part of the marketing strategy, and the buyer's broker is paid through escrow at closing from the seller's proceeds. When the seller does not offer buyer-broker compensation, or when the offer falls short of the buyer's representation agreement, the buyer pays the shortfall directly. This is fully negotiable in the purchase offer itself and is increasingly a routine point of negotiation.
Luxury-Specific Realities
LA luxury transactions involve services that go well beyond MLS access and showing logistics. They typically include: market intelligence and pricing analysis grounded in comparable sales not visible in public records; coordination with private wealth advisors, tax counsel, and trust attorneys; discretion management around marketing exposure (off-market, pre-MLS, private network); coordination with architects, contractors, designers, and inspectors during diligence; complex negotiation including counteroffer strategy across multiple parties; and escrow coordination with deals that frequently include trusts, LLCs, foreign-source funds, and other layered ownership structures.
The compensation conversation in LA luxury is appropriately a conversation about the full service set, not just the showing logistics. A 1 percent discount on commission that comes with reduced market intelligence, weaker negotiation experience, or thinner marketing can easily produce a 5 percent worse sale or purchase price — the math runs against the apparent savings.
Fee Structures Worth Considering
Beyond the conventional percentage-of-price model, several structures are appropriate for specific situations. Tiered listing commissions work well when seller and broker have a shared view on a likely price range but want to align incentives at the high end (lower percentage to a base figure, higher percentage on dollars above a target). Performance-based components (a base compensation plus a bonus contingent on achieving a price target or close-of-escrow milestone) align brokerage compensation with seller outcomes. Flat-fee buyer-side can be appropriate for buyers acquiring multiple properties of similar profile where the per-transaction work is repeatable. Hourly buyer representation can be appropriate for highly experienced buyers who use the broker for specific functions rather than full representation.
The best structure is the one that aligns the broker's economic incentive with the client's actual goal — which is sometimes lowest commission, sometimes highest price achieved, sometimes shortest time to close, and sometimes most discreet process. A good broker will discuss structure openly and propose alternatives where appropriate.
Dual Compensation and Disclosure
Dual compensation (a single broker representing both buyer and seller in the same transaction, or two agents from the same brokerage representing each side) is permitted in California with full written disclosure and consent. In LA luxury, dual compensation arises occasionally — particularly in pre-MLS or off-market transactions where the listing broker matches a known buyer to the property.
The buyer and seller should each understand what dual compensation means: the broker owes fiduciary duties to both parties and cannot advocate fully for either against the other on terms. Pricing analysis, negotiation strategy, and contingency advocacy are softened in dual-compensation arrangements. Whether that trade-off is acceptable depends on the parties' sophistication, the nature of the deal, and the alternatives. Disclosure should be explicit and the consent should be written.
What the Marketing Budget Buys
Sellers negotiating listing-side compensation should specifically ask what marketing investment is committed for what fee. In LA luxury, a competitive marketing package typically includes: professional architectural and lifestyle photography; cinematic video and aerial drone footage; a custom property website; print marketing in luxury publications relevant to the buyer pool; targeted digital advertising; international syndication for properties with global buyer appeal; broker open events and private showings; staging consultation or full staging; and discretion management for pre-market exposure.
Not every property requires every component, but the marketing scope should be explicitly defined in the listing agreement. A seller paying 5 percent total compensation for a $10M property is committing $500,000 in compensation; the marketing investment should be proportional. Patricia delivers this scope on every Elite Collective listing as a matter of practice — and the marketing plan is documented and discussed before listing, not improvised after.
How to Approach the Conversation
The right approach to a broker compensation conversation in LA luxury is to start with the service set you actually need, then evaluate which structure aligns broker incentives with that service set, and finally to discuss the headline figure in context. A broker who can articulate the marketing plan, the pricing rationale, the negotiation experience, and the post-close client management is selling a different product than a broker who can only quote a percentage.
For sellers: the right listing broker delivers measurable market intelligence, a defined marketing program, a clear pricing rationale, and the negotiation experience to achieve the highest market-clearing price. For buyers: the right buyer's broker delivers market intelligence on properties not visible in public records, structural diligence to identify risks early, negotiation experience on price and contingencies, and discretion across a process that may span months. Either side is poorly served by a commission-only conversation.
Frequently asked questions
Are commissions in LA fixed by anyone?
No. Real estate commissions in California are fully negotiable and have always been negotiable. There is no required or customary commission set by any law, association, or MLS. Each transaction's compensation is negotiated between the parties and disclosed in writing.
Does the seller always pay the buyer's broker?
Not always, and not by default. The seller may offer cooperative compensation to attract buyer-broker representation, but this is a marketing decision in the listing agreement, not a legal requirement. Buyers contract with their own broker through a written representation agreement and may pay the broker directly or accept the seller's cooperative offer through escrow.
Should I just choose the broker with the lowest commission?
Compensation is one input, not the only input. The broker's market intelligence, negotiation experience, marketing investment, network access, and post-close coordination affect transaction outcomes more than a percentage delta on commission. A 1 percent commission savings that costs 3 to 5 percent of sale price is bad math. The right framework is total value delivered, not lowest commission.
Is dual agency a good idea in LA luxury?
Dual agency works in some specific situations — pre-known buyer for an off-market property, family or trust transactions, or transactions where both parties prefer the same broker for discretion reasons. In a competitive bidding situation, dual agency softens the broker's ability to fully advocate for either side on terms. Buyers and sellers should understand the trade-off and consent only where the trade-off is acceptable to them.
Related Intelligence
Related reading from The Journal: