The Short Version
Highland Avenue is widely treated as a pricing line in the Manhattan Beach Sand Section. West of Highland, lots sit closer to The Strand, more often slope toward the ocean and carry view potential, so land value dominates price. East of Highland, still within the Sand Section, the grid flattens and value leans more on the structure, condition and lot. Reading comps correctly means stratifying by side of Highland, row, walk street versus drive street, condition and property type.
In This Article
Why One Avenue Carries So Much Weight
Highland Avenue runs north to south through the Manhattan Beach Sand Section, roughly parallel to the shoreline and a few blocks inland from The Strand. Local practitioners have long described it as a dividing line for property values closest to the beach, with land west of Highland typically commanding a meaningful premium over comparable land to the east. That observation is not folklore; it follows from how coastal land is priced.
In the Sand Section, lots are small, often under 3,000 square feet, and the housing stock has turned over repeatedly through rebuilds. When a buyer pays for a property west of Highland, much of the price is for the dirt: its distance to the sand, its elevation relative to neighbors and its potential for an ocean view from an upper level or roof deck. The structure matters, but it is often the more replaceable component.
East of Highland, the Sand Section continues inland, but the variables change. The walk to the beach lengthens, the grade flattens in many blocks and ocean views become harder to secure. Value there leans more heavily on the house itself: its age, its finish level, its layout and how efficiently it uses a small lot. For a broader view of how the Sand, Hill and Tree Sections compare, see our Sand, Hill and Tree Section comparison.
The Variables That Drive the Spread
Treating the Highland split as a single number is the most common analytical error we see. The spread between the two sides is the net result of several variables that move independently:
- Row from The Strand. A Strand-front lot, a first-row lot behind it and a lot several rows inland are different products. West of Highland covers several rows; the premium compresses quickly as rows increase.
- Walk street versus drive street. Many west-of-Highland walk streets are sloped toward the ocean, which creates view corridors. The South End also has flat walk streets east of Highland, which carry a pedestrian-street premium without the same view profile.
- View protection and elevation. A lot that sits high relative to its westerly neighbors can hold a view that a lower lot on the same block cannot.
- Condition and age. A dated house east of Highland and a current-spec rebuild east of Highland can sit far apart in price per square foot; the same is true west of Highland.
- Property type. Single-family residences, duplexes and condominium units trade in different buyer pools, and duplex product often prices at a discount in a market dominated by primary-residence buyers.
- North End versus South End. Proximity to downtown and the pier, and the character of individual blocks, shift value along the north-south axis as well.
When two sales on opposite sides of Highland differ by a large margin, the first task is to decompose that difference across these variables before attributing it to the avenue itself.
Land Value Versus Structure Value
The most useful lens for the Highland question is the split between land and improvements. In coastal Manhattan Beach, sales of older homes that are later demolished reveal what the market will pay for a lot alone. Comparing those land-driven sales on each side of Highland gives a cleaner read on the location premium than comparing finished houses, because it removes the noise of finish level and design.
A bottom-up valuation then adds a depreciated structure value to that land value. West of Highland, the land component frequently represents the large majority of total value, so a dated house can still trade at a high absolute price. East of Highland, the structure component is usually a larger share of the total, which is why renovation quality and construction age move price more noticeably there.
We advise clients to reconcile both methods: land plus depreciated structure, and comparable sales on a price-per-square-foot basis adjusted for row, street type and condition. If the two approaches disagree by more than about ten percent, something in the comp set or the assumptions needs a second look. Our discussion of renovated versus original condition spreads covers the structure side of that equation in more depth.
Zoning and Coastal Rules on Both Sides
Pricing also reflects what can be built. The beach area of Manhattan Beach falls within the California Coastal Zone, and the city's coastal standards largely track the residential development rules for its beach-area districts, identified in the zoning code as Area Districts III and IV. Height, buildable floor area, setbacks and parking requirements in those districts shape the maximum house a lot can carry, and therefore the land value.
Because zoning designations vary block by block, some parcels on either side of Highland permit more than one unit while others are limited to a single residence. A lot that can legally carry a duplex or a larger floor area is not directly comparable to one that cannot, even on the same street. Before relying on any comparison across Highland, confirm the zone, the applicable area district and any coastal permit history with the City of Manhattan Beach Planning Division. Standards are revised from time to time, so a figure that held for a 2019 rebuild may not apply to a 2026 plan.
Reading Comps Across the Line
Manhattan Beach Sand Section sales volume is thin in any given quarter, and the small sample creates false signals. A single Strand-adjacent sale can pull a monthly average sharply upward, while a run of east-of-Highland condominium sales can pull it down, with neither reflecting a change in underlying value. Our note on small-sample statistics in ultra-luxury explains why averages mislead in markets like this one.
A disciplined comp process for a Sand Section property generally looks like this:
- Start with closed sales from the last 24 months on the same side of Highland, the same row band and the same street type.
- Separate single-family residences from duplexes and condominiums before computing any price per square foot.
- Group by condition: recently renovated or newer construction, renovated five to fifteen years ago, and dated.
- Time-adjust older sales to current conditions using a supportable rate, as described in our guide to comp time adjustments.
- Treat prior list prices, including withdrawn listings, as evidence of where buyers resisted.
Only after that stratification is complete should a comparison across Highland be made, and then with explicit adjustments that can be traced and audited.
Strategy for Buyers and Sellers
For buyers, the Highland line is a question of what the premium actually purchases. A west-of-Highland property several rows back with no protected view may offer less of the coastal benefit than its address implies, while an east-of-Highland home on a walk street can deliver a pedestrian setting and a short walk to the sand at a lower land basis. Visiting at different times of day, measuring the actual walk and confirming view lines from the upper level are more informative than the side of the avenue alone.
For sellers, the line determines which buyers and which comps will frame the conversation. A west-of-Highland seller with a dated structure is often selling land, and pricing should anchor to land-driven sales rather than to renovated product. An east-of-Highland seller with a recent, well-executed rebuild should position against finished-product comps and be ready to document construction quality, permits and systems. In both cases, list price strategy should account for the thin buyer pool at the top of the market.
Our market pages track Manhattan Beach conditions, and we prepare property-specific comp sets for clients weighing a purchase or sale on either side of Highland.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Highland Avenue the boundary of the Sand Section?
No. Highland Avenue runs through the Sand Section rather than bounding it. Properties on both sides of Highland are commonly considered Sand Section. The avenue matters because it marks a practical shift in distance to the beach, grade and view potential, which local agents and appraisers have long observed as a dividing line for land value.
Why is land worth more west of Highland?
West of Highland, lots are closer to The Strand, many sit on sloped streets that create ocean view corridors, and the walk to the sand is shorter. Because Sand Section lots are small and frequently rebuilt, buyers are largely paying for location. Those location attributes are scarcer east of Highland, so land there generally commands less.
Are walk streets only found west of Highland?
No. Many of the best-known sloped walk streets are west of Highland near the beach, but the South End also includes flat walk streets east of Highland. Those streets carry a pedestrian-street benefit but usually lack the same view profile, so they should be compared with each other rather than with west-of-Highland walk streets.
Can I compare a duplex and a single-family home across Highland?
Not directly. Duplexes, condominiums and single-family residences attract different buyers and are valued differently, and duplex product often trades at a discount where primary-residence buyers dominate. Separate the property types first, then compare like with like on each side of Highland, adjusting for row, street type and condition.
How recent should comparable sales be?
We prefer closed sales within the last 24 months. Older sales can still be informative, but they should be time-adjusted to current conditions using a supportable rate drawn from recent trends. Prior list prices, including withdrawn listings, also provide useful evidence of where buyers have declined to transact.
Weighing a property near Highland?
We build stratified comp sets that separate row, street type, condition and property type, so you can see what the Highland premium is actually buying. Schedule a strategy call, or visit Buyers and Sellers.
Schedule a Strategy CallPatricia Blakemore · Elite Collective
Direct: (213) 319-3040
Toll Free: (844) 475-0999
Email: [email protected]
Address: Manhattan Beach, California 90266
Web: www.elitecollectiverealty.com
CalDRE# 02079554 · Patricia Blakemore, Broker/Owner · Elite Collective Realty
