The Short Version
When California real property is sold, the escrow holder generally must withhold state income tax and remit it to the Franchise Tax Board unless an exemption applies. The default is 3 1/3% of the sales price. A seller may instead elect withholding based on estimated gain, which for individuals uses 12.3%. Common exemptions include a qualifying principal residence and a sale at a loss. Unlike FIRPTA, Form 593 applies to California residents and nonresidents alike, and the amount withheld is a credit, not a final tax.
In This Article
What Form 593 is and why it exists
California's real estate withholding rules are designed to collect income tax on gains from property sales at the moment cash changes hands, rather than relying entirely on the seller to report the sale months later. The mechanism is Form 593, the Real Estate Withholding Statement, which the seller completes and signs and the escrow holder files with the Franchise Tax Board (FTB).
Withholding is not an additional tax. It is a prepayment. The seller reports the sale on the appropriate California return for the year and claims the amount withheld as a credit. If more was withheld than the tax ultimately owed, the difference is refunded through the return. If less was withheld, the seller pays the balance. For a seller planning the use of proceeds, however, a withheld amount is unavailable until the return is processed, which is why it belongs in the seller net sheet from the start.
Who withholds and when
The FTB calls the party responsible the Real Estate Escrow Person, or REEP: the person or entity that receives and disburses the funds at closing, typically the escrow or title company, an attorney acting in that role or, in a deferred exchange, the qualified intermediary. The REEP must notify the buyer of the withholding requirements, collect the withholding from the seller's proceeds and remit it.
According to the FTB's 2026 instructions, Form 593 and the payment are due by the 20th day of the month following the month escrow closes, and the seller must receive a copy within the same window. The seller signs the certification on the form before closing. A seller who knowingly submits a false certification to avoid withholding faces a penalty of $1,000 or 20% of the required withholding, whichever is greater. Because escrow handles the filing, sellers rarely interact with the FTB directly during the transaction, but they are responsible for the accuracy of what they certify.
The default rate and the gain-on-sale election
Under the standard method, the escrow holder withholds 3 1/3% of the total sales price. On a high-value sale, that is a significant amount of cash, and it is calculated on price, not profit, so a seller with a modest gain can see withholding well above the eventual tax.
The alternative is the optional gain-on-sale election. The seller estimates the gain on the transaction and withholding is calculated by applying the rate for the seller's entity type. The FTB's 2026 instructions list the rates, including:
- Individuals and trusts: 12.3%
- Non-California partnerships: 12.3%
- Corporations: 8.84%
- S corporations: 13.8%
For a long-held property with a low basis, the gain-based calculation may produce a higher figure than the default. For a recent purchase or a property with substantial capital improvements, it can produce a much lower one. The estimate must be made in good faith and cannot show a loss when the seller actually has a gain. We advise sellers to have their CPA run both calculations before escrow opens.
Exemptions that commonly apply
Many luxury sales fall within an exemption. The FTB instructions identify full exemptions that include:
- Principal residence. The property qualifies as the seller's principal residence under Internal Revenue Code Section 121, generally owned and used as a home for two of the five years before sale, or was last used as the seller's principal residence. Our guide to Section 121 for California homeowners explains the underlying test.
- Loss or zero gain on the sale.
- Involuntary conversions under Section 1033.
- Certain entities, such as qualifying corporations with a permanent place of business in California, tax-exempt organizations and specified retirement plans and trusts.
Withholding is also not required when the sales price is $100,000 or less, in certain foreclosures and in some sales by a bank acting as trustee. Partial treatment applies to like-kind exchanges, where withholding generally reaches only cash or other property exceeding $1,500 received by the seller, and to installment sales, where the buyer withholds on principal payments. Our article on 1031 exchange identification covers the exchange timeline.
An exemption from withholding is not an exemption from tax. A seller whose principal residence gain exceeds the federal exclusion still reports and pays California tax on the excess.
How Form 593 differs from FIRPTA
Sellers sometimes confuse California withholding with the federal Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act. The two operate independently and can both apply to the same sale.
- Who it covers. FIRPTA applies only to foreign sellers. Form 593 applies to California residents, nonresidents and entities alike, unless an exemption applies.
- Rate and base. FIRPTA generally requires withholding of 15% of the amount realized, subject to specific reductions and exceptions. Form 593 defaults to 3 1/3% of the sales price or the elected gain-based amount.
- Who files. Under FIRPTA the buyer is the withholding agent, though escrow typically administers it. Under Form 593 the escrow person files with the FTB.
A foreign seller of a California property may face both. Our guide to FIRPTA withholding explains the federal side.
Planning before you list
The time to address Form 593 is before escrow opens, not the week of closing. We recommend that sellers gather purchase documents, records of capital improvements and prior depreciation for any rental use, then review with a CPA whether an exemption applies or whether the gain-based election would reduce withholding. Sellers holding property in a trust, LLC or partnership should confirm how the entity type affects the analysis, and sellers who rented the home should review how that use interacts with the principal residence exemption.
Timing matters because the certification is fixed at closing. According to the FTB's instructions, once escrow closes, an over-withholding cannot be undone by amending Form 593; the seller recovers it only by claiming the credit on the tax return for the year of sale. Sellers should also confirm that escrow is using the current-year version of the form, as the FTB updates it annually.
Escrow officers can explain the form, but they do not provide tax advice. Planning this element early is part of how we prepare sellers for a predictable closing and an accurate view of net proceeds.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Form 593 withholding an extra tax on my sale?
No. It is a prepayment of California income tax. The seller reports the sale on the appropriate state return and claims the amount withheld as a credit. If the withholding exceeds the tax owed, the excess is refunded through the return. If it falls short, the seller pays the remaining balance.
Do I owe withholding if I am selling my primary home?
Often not. The FTB provides a full exemption when the property qualifies as the seller's principal residence under Internal Revenue Code Section 121 or was last used as the seller's principal residence. The seller certifies this on Form 593. Any gain above the federal exclusion may still be taxable on the return.
What is the alternative withholding calculation?
It is an optional election that bases withholding on the seller's estimated gain rather than the sales price. The estimated gain is multiplied by a rate set by entity type, such as 12.3% for individuals according to the 2026 instructions. It can reduce withholding for sellers with high basis or substantial documented improvements.
Who files Form 593 with the Franchise Tax Board?
The Real Estate Escrow Person, usually the escrow or title company handling the closing, or a qualified intermediary in a deferred exchange. The seller completes and signs the certification before closing. The form and payment are due by the 20th day of the month after the month escrow closes.
Can both Form 593 and FIRPTA apply to the same sale?
Yes. FIRPTA is a federal regime that applies only to foreign sellers, while Form 593 is California's regime and applies to residents and nonresidents alike unless an exemption applies. A foreign seller of California property may therefore face both, and each has its own exemptions, rates and filing process.
Planning a sale and want clarity on net proceeds?
We help sellers prepare early with their tax advisors, so withholding, exemptions and net proceeds are understood before the property goes to market. Schedule a strategy call, or visit Buyers and Sellers.
Schedule a Strategy CallPatricia Blakemore · Elite Collective
Direct: (213) 319-3040
Toll Free: (844) 475-0999
Email: [email protected]
Address: Manhattan Beach, California 90266
Web: www.elitecollectiverealty.com
CalDRE# 02079554 · Patricia Blakemore, Broker/Owner · Elite Collective Realty
